Research Article |
|
Corresponding author: Chiara Manfrin ( cmanfrin@units.it ) Academic editor: Lukas Landler
© 2026 Marco Restaino, Chiara Manfrin.
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
Restaino M, Manfrin C (2026) Non-invasive UV-A photo-identification for individual recognition in olms (genus Proteus). Herpetozoa 39: 429-440. https://doi.org/10.3897/herpetozoa.39.e208806
|
The cave salamander Proteus represents a flagship and keystone genus of the subterranean ecosystems of the Dinaric Karst. Currently classified as “Vulnerable” by the International Union for Conservation of Nature, its long-term monitoring is essential for understanding subterranean ecosystem dynamics and for guiding evidence-based conservation strategies.
Given its protected status and the strict permitting requirements for research and monitoring, the development of non-invasive protocols is of paramount importance.
The present study aims to present a non-invasive, underwater-capable photographic tracking method for this highly vulnerable subterranean species that minimizes handling-related stress and potential impacts on animal welfare. Specifically, this work explores the application of UV photography as a novel tool for the detection and characterization of individual skin patterns, enabling the recognition of over 300 individual specimens based on unique and naturally occurring morphological features. By providing a reliable means of distinguishing individuals without the need for invasive or potentially stressful traditional marking techniques, such as physical tagging, UV-based imaging may represent a valuable alternative for the long-term monitoring of olm populations.
This approach contributes to the development of scientifically grounded, welfare-centered monitoring protocols that effectively balance conservation requirements with the highest standards of animal care while improving the accuracy, repeatability, and ethical sustainability of individual-based ecological studies. Importantly, although recent evidence has revealed the presence of at least two distinct Proteus species within the study area, the present imaging-based approach remains effective for the individual identification of specimens across both species. This demonstrates that the method captures sufficient inter-individual variation to reliably distinguish individuals, irrespective of their species identity, highlighting its robustness and broad applicability in sympatric Proteus spp. populations.
365 nm UV light, 395 nm UV light, biofluorescence, cryptic species, individual recognition, olm, UV-A
Over recent decades, the well-documented global decline of amphibians (
While marking and tracking techniques have substantially advanced ecological research and biodiversity conservation, they remain controversial due to their intrusiveness and impacts that are often insufficiently evaluated prior to application. Reliable but relatively unintrusive marking methods are required to observe populations in their natural habitat over long periods of time (
Proteus spp. are neotenic cave salamanders endemic to the Dinaric Karst and are widely regarded as a priority genus of exceptional conservation and scientific value. The genus is currently classified as “Vulnerable” by the International Union for Conservation of Nature and is listed in Annex II (requiring special conservation areas) and Annex IV (requiring strict protection of habitats and species) of the EU Habitats Directive (92/43/EEC) as P. anguinus s.l., and research and monitoring are conducted only under special permits issued by national authorities. As obligate stygobiotic vertebrates inhabiting oligotrophic, well-oxygenated groundwater systems in limestone and dolomitic formations, these salamanders are highly sensitive to environmental perturbations, including groundwater contamination, hydrological alterations, and disruption of aquifer connectivity (
Recently, nine distinct species have been recognized. Among them, the Ljubljanica and Kras/Carso lineages, previously identified by
Among the methods available for individual identification in amphibians and other taxa, Visible Implant Elastomer (VIE) tagging is one of the most widely used in salamanders (
In olm research, VIE is currently the most commonly applied marking technique (
Currently, UV photography or filming is applied to several taxa, even those largely unrelated to one another. Mammals, such as the eastern mole (Scalopus aquaticus) and various flying squirrels and bats, exhibit bright, species-specific or individual-specific pink, green, or yellow fluorescence on their fur when exposed to 365–395 nm UV light (
Studies have found that 37 out of 45 bird-of-paradise species exhibit biofluorescence in their feathers. Specific areas, such as the beaks of Atlantic puffins (
For invertebrates, UV light is often used by taxonomists to visualize specific fluorescent patterns on the scales (elytra) of polychaete worms (Harmothoe impar), and UV light also aids in detecting otherwise invisible invertebrates, such as mites on a brittlestar (
The patterns revealed under different wavelengths have been shown to be highly effective in distinguishing natural markings and morphological features, thereby enabling the identification of intraspecific variation within a population. The recognition method used in this study exploits the biofluorescence of proteids as a distinctive feature, enabling their identification based on the emitted optical signal. This approach is supported by previous observations of biofluorescence in amphibians, with
As part of an ongoing monitoring program of the Proteus spp. populations in the Classical Karst of Italy, approximately 300 individual olms have so far been photographed under visible light, infrared light, and ultraviolet light at two different wavelengths. The aim is to enable reliable individual identification without the need for more invasive marking techniques. The present study proposes this UV-A imaging-based approach as a reliable method for the individual identification of specimens belonging to at least two Proteus species. Its virtually non-invasive nature, cost-effectiveness, and ease of application make it particularly suitable for research groups, whereas its effectiveness in enabling the individual identification of animals from both sympatric species demonstrates its broad applicability within the study area. Moreover, the method does not require highly specialized equipment or substantial financial investment, making it an accessible and practical approach for long-term monitoring and conservation programs. Importantly, although recent evidence (
Three hundred and three olms collected from nine different caves in the Italian Classical Karst (Trieste and Gorizia provinces, Italy) (Fig.
Map of the study area. The provinces of Trieste and Gorizia are highlighted in yellow, while the Classical Karst, which extends beyond the Italian border, is shown in shades of red. Blue lines represent rivers. The principal underground flow path of the Reka–Timavo River is indicated from A to B, and dotted blue arrows schematically illustrate diffuse groundwater inflows from the surrounding karst aquifer.
Sampled caves where olms were recorded, alongside their unique National and Regional Cadastral Number (N/RCN) and the total number of olms recorded.
| Cave | National/Regional Cadastral Number | Number of specimens recorded |
|---|---|---|
| Trebiciano | 3/17VG | 198 |
| Luftloch | 7477/6442VG | 30 |
| Abisso di Repen | 906/4035VG | 6 |
| Pozzo della Ferrovia | 214/226VG | 17 |
| Grotta del Proteo | 1191/4112VG | 9 |
| Pozzo di Vermegliano | 4306/5386VG | 28 |
| Cavernetta presso Comarie | 1287/4221VG | 2 |
| Pozzo presso Jamiano | 273/360VG | 11 |
| Grotta Andrea | 2391/4804VG | 2 |
Sampling was conducted as part of an ongoing long-term monitoring program covering the target area, which started on 1 August 2025 and is still continuing. In addition, a small portion of the tail fin was collected from each individual to obtain high-quality DNA for subsequent genetic analyses (Manfrin et al. in revision).
The required equipment included a mobile phone or camera, a headlamp, already part of the standard equipment necessary for cave exploration, UV-A torches (365 and 395 nm), and an IR-light torch. The simplest camera apparatus used to acquire olm pictures was a 12 MP camera on a mobile phone (Samsung Galaxy S21), and the most professional camera used was an OM-5 Mark II with an M.Zuiko 12-45/4 Pro 20.4 MP lens (OM System). Pictures were collected in RAW or JPG formats, based on the apparatus available during each field activity.
Repeated visits to the same caves throughout the monitoring campaign enabled the identification of individual olms and the documentation of recapture events, with a total field effort of 77 days. Following morphometric measurements, exposure to UV-A light was kept to a minimum, with less than 30 s required per individual to acquire multiple photographs of the dorsal side. Upon first capture, each olm underwent tail clipping for genetic analyses (Manfrin et al. in revision). Individual identification was based on the distinctive skin pigmentation patterns visible under UV illumination rather than on tail clipping. Particular attention was paid to the head and dorsal body regions, where patterns were assessed based on the presence, position, and configuration of distinctive markings. Each olm was photographed under each light condition, with a minimum of three and up to 10 images per condition. Photographs were subsequently organized into folders corresponding to identified individuals. For each specimen, photographs were systematically compared with the complete reference collection of previously identified individuals, displayed simultaneously on separate screens. Thus, each newly captured individual was assessed against all previously identified specimens rather than against a subset of individuals. Identification involved the assessment of both concordant and discordant patterns to determine whether the newly captured individual matched a previously identified specimen. Individuals captured only once also exhibited highly distinctive and readily discernible patterns that allowed them to be distinguished from other individuals sampled at the same cave. To ensure the reliability and independence of the identification process, each photographic comparison was carried out independently and blindly by at least two observers, each working without knowledge of the other’s assignment. At least one observer had participated in the field sampling, whereas the other had not and was therefore unaware of tail-clipping information. The latter assessments were based exclusively on photographic records, together with information on the capture site and morphometric measurements (e.g., body length and weight) of previously recorded and newly captured specimens. During fieldwork, samples were labeled only with progressive numbers and were not assigned individual IDs. Individual IDs were subsequently assigned through photographic analysis. Consequently, information on tail clipping available to field observers was not used to assign individual identities and could only be compared retrospectively with photo-based identifications, providing an independent posterior validation of the UV-based identification method. An individual was classified as a recapture only when its photographic characteristics were considered consistent with those of a previously identified individual by at least two independent observers. Tail clipping was therefore not used as a primary criterion for individual identification but rather as a secondary mark assessed retrospectively to avoid false rejection, i.e., failure to recognize a previously captured individual. Although the tail can regenerate, the regenerated portion remains distinguishable from the previously clipped portion because of its different pigmentation (see Suppl. material
To date, 303 olms have been captured during 77 days of fieldwork across the provinces of Trieste and Gorizia, within the Italian Classical Karst, accounting for a total of 350 capture events. All individuals were photographed and photo-identified before being released. To assess whether different wavelengths could enhance the visibility of individual morphological features, images of each specimen were acquired under different wavelengths (Fig.
Specifically, visible light allowed the recognition of amputated appendages, hematomas on the body, and other morphological malformations. Among the tested wavelengths, infrared (IR) illumination was the least effective and did not enhance the detection of individual body patterns or improve identification success (Fig.
Comparison of UV pictures allowed the recognition of individual-specific body signatures, enabling reliable individual photo-identification of all captured olms. Consequently, long-term monitoring is being conducted exclusively using visible-light and 365/395 nm UV-light photography.
At 365 nm, the highest fluorescence was observed, highlighting body signatures that were very useful for individual recognition (Figs
Moreover, using 395 nm UV light, it was possible to define additional spots that were less abundant but characteristic for individual recognition (Fig.
Regardless of species, the non-uniform distribution of these fluorescent compounds across the skin surface generates stable spot patterns that appear to be unique to each specimen (Fig.
Pictures of the same olm. A. 365 nm UV light. White arrows indicate hypopigmentation (head) and hyperpigmentation (limb insertion); B. 395 nm UV light. Green arrows indicate specific greenish spots; C. Mixed UV-A light with both individual markers shown with corresponding-colored arrows. Photo credit: Marco Restaino.
No detectable shifts in the position, shape, or arrangement of the fluorescent spots were observed, allowing the unequivocal recognition, as exemplified in Fig.
365 nm UV-light images of the same olm taken on 17 August 2025 (A) and 25 February 2026 (B). Green arrows indicate individual spots on the head, white and red arrows indicate specific spot clusters on the anterior trunk, and yellow and purple arrows indicate spot clusters on the middle trunk. Juxtaposed images of the juvenile head of another specimen, showing the same individual at its first capture (C) and more than one year later (D), with arrows indicating persistent individual markers. Photo credit: Chiara Manfrin.
During the ongoing monitoring, the longest time elapsed between capture and recapture was approximately 12 months. No modification in skin pattern was observed under 365 nm UV illumination, even in juveniles (Fig.
To date, a total of 303 olms have been documented, totaling 350 captures, across nine caves (Table
Over the course of a year of monitoring, none of the recaptured specimens showed any changes or reductions in their skin markings, whether juveniles or adults (Fig.
The UV-picture-based method is sustainable in comparison with the costs of VIE tagging (Table
Cost and operational comparison between VIE elastomer tagging and UV torch-based photographic identification for individual recognition. An explanation of the calculation of identification efficiency is provided in Suppl. material
| Component | VIE-tagging | UV-photo identification | Conclusion |
|---|---|---|---|
| Identification efficiency | 61 VIE-tagged olms = 84.7% (n = 72); four too small to tag, seven not tagged ( |
All 303 olms were photographed and individually identified = 100% (n = 303; present study) | Both methods enable individual recognition, but UV-photo identification can be applied to all captured individuals |
| Estimated lifetime of the mark | ≥ 4 years ( |
≥ 1 year demonstrated; potentially persistent over the animal’s lifetime | Both methods have potential for long-term monitoring |
| Minimum individual weight | 5 g ( |
2.6 g (present study) | UV-photo identification is suitable for smaller individuals |
| Initial equipment | Injection kit, syringes and VIE elastomer | UV torch and camera/smartphone | Both methods require simple equipment |
| Consumables | Elastomer must be regularly replenished; mixed aliquots have a working time of approximately 45 min–2 h, depending on temperature | No consumables; only electrical equipment requires recharging | UV-photo identification requires no consumables |
| Per-animal cost | Moderate: elastomer is consumed for each individual | Negligible after initial equipment purchase | UV-photo identification has lower per-animal costs |
| Processing time: field | Injection required (< 3 min per specimen) | Illumination and photography (< 30 s per specimen) | UV-photo identification requires less handling and processing time in the field |
| Processing time: identification | Time required to check tag codes; not reported | Visual comparison with the photographic database (1–15 min, depending on the number of specimens collected per cave) | Processing times for individual recognition are not directly comparable |
| Animal handling | Relatively long and invasive | Short and non-invasive when photographing directly; minimally invasive if temporary containment is required | UV-photo identification requires substantially less handling |
| Potential animal stress | Direct handling without anesthesia for < 3 min, plus light exposure during tag identification ( |
Direct UV-A exposure for < 30 s at a distance of ≥ 35–40 cm | Both methods involve animal handling/light exposure, but VIE tagging involves longer handling |
| Individual identification | Excellent | Excellent: distinctive natural fluorescent patterns enabled the identification of > 300 olms | Both methods provide highly effective individual recognition; UV-photo identification relies on natural markers |
| Technical difficulty | Requires specific training in VIE tagging | Relatively simple photographic procedure | UV-photo identification requires less specialized training |
VIE tagging: (i) initial kit: €245–1,138 (US$280–1,300); (ii) additional elastomer may be needed depending on the number of marks/colors; and (iii) significant labor for injection.
UV photography: (i) UV flashlight: €15–150 (US$17–169); (ii) digital camera or smartphone (often already available); (iii) essentially no consumable costs; and (iv) faster processing in the field.
Overall, both methods enable reliable long-term individual recognition. However, UV-photo identification offers several practical advantages: it is non-invasive, requires minimal handling, is suitable for small individuals, involves no consumables, has negligible per-animal costs, and can be applied to all captured specimens.
In this study, the reliability of UV-A-assisted photographic identification as a non-invasive method for recognizing a large set of Proteus spp. was evaluated, with 303 olms individually recognized. Because the olm is a blind cave salamander adapted to absolute darkness, limited and very brief (<30 s) UV-A light exposure was maintained within a strict time limit, and no behavioral flight responses were observed.
The approach requires no animal marking or handling beyond routine morpho-photographic documentation and relies on naturally occurring fluorescent skin patterns visible under ultraviolet illumination. Similar fluorescence- or pattern-based approaches have been successfully applied in other amphibians and wildlife species, where naturally occurring skin or integument patterns provide stable individual identifiers (
All recaptured olms were successfully identified through comparison of their UV fluorescence patterns, demonstrating that these markings provide sufficient variation for reliable individual recognition. Across 303 examined individuals distributed over nine hypogean sites, no two specimens exhibited the same arrangement of fluorescent spots, suggesting that these patterns function as natural “fingerprints.” The method was also effective in juveniles and subadults, with distinctive patterns clearly visible in individuals approximately 10 cm in total length. This represents an important advantage over conventional marking techniques such as Visible Implant Elastomer (VIE) tags or Passive Integrated Transponder (PIT) tags, which become increasingly invasive or technically challenging in small-bodied animals.
The fluorescent markings are likely associated with riboflavin-like compounds naturally present in the skin of Proteus (
From a practical perspective, UV-A-assisted photographic identification offers several advantages over traditional marking techniques. The method requires only portable UV light sources and a digital camera or smartphone, eliminating the need for consumable marking materials, specialized equipment, or artificial identification codes. Following the initial equipment purchase, the per-animal cost is essentially negligible, making the approach particularly attractive for long-term monitoring programs involving repeated surveys.
Importantly, the method removes the need for invasive marking procedures when the objective is solely individual identification. Although tissue sampling remains essential for studies requiring high-quality DNA or RNA, including population genomics, transcriptomics, and parentage analyses, it is unnecessary for routine identification because naturally occurring fluorescence patterns provide sufficient discriminatory power. Consequently, UV-assisted photographic identification complements rather than replaces molecular sampling by restricting invasive procedures to studies in which they are scientifically justified.
The method also proved practical for relatively large datasets. To date, this monitoring campaign represents the largest sampling ever conducted on olm populations in their natural distributional range, to current knowledge (
Individual recognition was performed by comparing photographs from each capture event with all previously collected images, taking into account the overall skin pattern rather than relying on a single mark. The tail clip was used as a secondary identification mark to minimize the risk of false rejections and to validate the method proposed in the present study; however, it is not required for the application of the proposed method. The creation of standardized photographic catalogs (“photo passports”) facilitates rapid field identification and long-term monitoring. Although manual comparison was effective in the present study, future developments could further improve efficiency. Machine-learning and artificial intelligence approaches are currently being developed by the research group to automate the recognition of olm UV fluorescence patterns, and this approach has already been used to enable rapid matching among thousands of images while reducing observer bias (
With growing attention to animal welfare, recent studies increasingly highlight the value of photo-identification as a reliable and less invasive alternative to artificial tagging. In particular, photo-identification can be effectively applied to juvenile frogs (
The ability to identify individual animals is fundamental to ecological research (
Overall, UV-assisted photographic identification combines high discriminatory power with minimal invasiveness, low cost, and ease of implementation. By eliminating the need for artificial, stressful, or physically invasive marking while maintaining reliable, long-term individual recognition, this method represents a highly valuable tool for capture-recapture studies and long-term conservation monitoring of vulnerable cave salamanders belonging to the genus Proteus.
The identification of stable, natural “fingerprints” using 365 nm and 395 nm UV wavelengths provides a solution to the welfare-related challenges historically associated with monitoring delicate, subterranean organisms. By facilitating rapid, low-stress documentation, even underwater, this approach sets a new standard for ethically conscious, non-invasive amphibian research.
Furthermore, the implications of this study extend beyond the Classical Karst area. The successful development of this photographic workflow suggests that UV-assisted identification may be readily applicable to other olm genetic lineages and rare, threatened, or cave-dwelling species that exhibit individually distinctive fluorescent structures or subtle pigmentation patterns. As wildlife monitoring increasingly prioritizes both high-resolution data collection and the highest standards of animal welfare, accessible methods like the one presented here will be crucial in balancing conservation priorities with non-invasive scientific inquiry.
The authors thank Edgardo Mauri for his advocacy of non-invasive wildlife monitoring, which greatly inspired the shift toward alternative olm monitoring protocols in this study. The authors are grateful to Dr. Migliorini for allowing fieldwork on his property and to the Comune di Trieste - Museo Civico di Storia Naturale di Trieste for hosting the development of these new identification methods. Finally, the authors extend their deep appreciation to Massimiliano Werk, Sergio Dambrosi, and all the cavers of the Società Adriatica di Speleologia for their invaluable cooperation and field support throughout this study.
The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Field sampling and surveys of Proteus a. anguinus were conducted under Permits No. 144200 (1 August 2025) and No. 14324 (22 January 2026) issued by the Italian Ministry of Environment and Energy Security.
The authors accept full responsibility for the content of the manuscript, including the disclosure of any use of AI.
During the preparation of this work, the authors used Claude.ai in order to improve the readability and language. Following the use of this tool, the authors reviewed and edited the content as necessary and take full responsibility for the content of the publication.
No funding was reported.
MR and CM conceived the ideas, designed the methodology, and collected and analyzed the data; CM led the writing of the manuscript. All authors contributed critically to the drafts and gave final approval for publication.
C. Manfrin https://orcid.org/0000-0002-4979-8557
The complete photographic database compiled during this study is available from the corresponding author upon reasonable request. The authors welcome and encourage collaboration with fellow researchers working on Proteus spp. The authors are open to cross-referencing photographic catalogs, comparing regional spot-pattern variations, and providing technical support or guidance to groups interested in implementing this non-invasive monitoring method at their own study sites.
Supplementary information
Data type: pdf
Explanation note: 1. Representative examples of different olms recorded under the three selected lighting conditions. 2. Recognition efficiency between VIE tagging and UV-photo identification: calculations. 3. Detail of the regenerated tail.